Four Harmonies
After his enlightenment, the Buddha hesitated before he set off to teach. But when he saw that there were people who could benefit from what he had realized, love welled up in him, and with a hearty, “Giddyup!” he set the great stagecoach of the Dharma in motion. This was the moment of inception of the Sangha. It was not born from the Buddha’s awakening or from his capacity to generate a coherent teaching. It was born from his compassion, or, to put it blandly, from his failure to be stingy. This is the core of participating in Sangha life.
A Sangha is any self-governed community that organizes and orients itself around the pursuit of Awakening. Most of the accounts of Sangha governance that survive in the Buddhist canon are concerned with monastic life, but the principles are applicable anywhere people gather together to practice the Dharma. I think that the historical Sangha is worthy of study and reverence. It is a source of inspiration and the vehicle that has carried the Dharma into the modern age, but I find it doubtful that an institution that grew piecemeal in the forests of ancient India could be perfectly adapted to a post-industrial, global community. Still, there are four things that modern Sangha members must hold in common to maintain the integrity of the Buddhist practice community:
- Kindness towards one another,
- The orientation towards the Four Noble Truths,
- Shared virtue (or precepts,) and
- Shared resources.
Be Excellent to Each Other
My teacher would say that there is no higher principle than that of brotherhood and sisterhood. If your spiritual practice alienates you from the simple joy of loving and revering your peers, it has failed the test of authenticity. Let’s say that you are sitting in meditation, and you can hear some raucous activity in the next room. If you become irritated, thinking to yourself, “Don’t they know that I’m trying to meditate in here?” then your meditation has failed. But, if your surroundings are completely peaceful, and you think to yourself, “Ah! Finally I can enjoy my meditation without being disturbed,” your meditation has also failed. You may sit peacefully for hours, but if you create opposition between yourself and the world, if your peace is something that you have to defend with harsh thoughts, harsh speech, harsh actions, then your meditation has been a waste.
This first item is traditionally divided up into three kinds of “warm-hearted” actions: those of body, speech, and mind. Actually, this is the best way to interact with everyone. The special point of participating in a Sangha is that the commitment is shared. If someone at the supermarket speaks to you with harsh words, that is their prerogative. You will have to find some way to deal with it. In the Sangha, however, if anger, hatred, blame, jealousy, suspicion, derision, or any other manner of unkindness arises, it is a collective problem. There is an accord in place that turns negativity into an opportunity for shared attention, compassion, and ultimately transformation. That is the first thing that is held in common by the members of a Sangha.
Right View
The second thing held in common is traditionally presented as Right View. This is the most important one, the one that makes the Sangha one of the Three Jewels. According to the Buddha, “Of these warm-hearted qualities, the chief is the view that is noble and emancipating, and delivers one who applies it to the complete ending of suffering. It holds and binds everything together. It’s like an A-frame house. The roof-peak is the chief point, which holds and binds everything together.”
There are lots of kinds of meditation. You can meditate to excel in your field, to enhance your creativity, to seek contact with spiritual realms, to ponder metaphysical questions, to entertain yourself, but it will not be Buddhist meditation. Buddhist meditation is oriented toward putting a decisive end to suffering. I do not think that this clarity can be easily contained in a sweeping statement. It takes time to develop an internal compass for discerning what leads to lasting wellbeing, but this is the test that all practices must be put to before they can be certified as Dharma.
In Sangha discussions, this is the anchor that keeps things real. I remember once when I was on a teaching tour as a monk, I sat down with a group of Sangha organizers in London. A man there asked for my opinion of breath meditation, and what techniques I preferred. We launched into a discussion of the intricacies of breath versus body awareness, what the strengths and shortcomings were of each practice, to the point of ignoring everyone else at the gathering. Finally, a woman in the corner of the room said, with barely restrained exasperation, “Isn’t the point of practice to know that we’re alive?”
Being good at meditation is irrelevant. Knowing how to practice is irrelevant. Having an opinion is irrelevant. You’re either fully living right now, or you’re being swept away by delusion, right now. Working together with a Sangha is the best way to see which one you’re doing.
Virtue
Virtue here means ethical conduct, conduct that is “intact, impeccable, spotless, and unmarred, liberating, praised by sensible people, not mistaken, and leading to immersion.” Notice the final point. We need a way of relating that can water the seeds of presence, concentration, and awakening, in ourselves and in one another. To support this, we have the practice of precepts.
Master Guishan says, “Associating with wise friends is like walking in the mist; your clothes will be permeated with moisture.” On the one hand, it isn’t something you need to force. On the other, it doesn’t happen all at once. Slowly, the seeds of hatred, craving, sorrow and confusion in your store consciousness will dry up, and the seeds of love and understanding will germinate and flourish. But it is hard to assess your progress in real time. You may not even notice the most meaningful changes. How can you imagine what the landscape of your mind will be like a year from now, a decade from now?
Let’s say that you want to completely transform your hatred. If you try to transform it directly, you may be discouraged. That seed has been heedlessly watered for a long time. The simple vow, “I will never hate again!” may be difficult to keep. But what about the vow, “I will refrain from killing human beings out of hatred.” Can you keep that one? Precepts help to make transformation concrete, verifiable, and accessible. Take the following hypothetical series of precepts, in order of decreasing gravity:
- I will refrain from killing living beings out of hatred.
- I will refrain from striking living beings out of hatred.
- I will refrain from speaking harshly out of hatred.
- I will refrain from thinking critical or derisive thoughts out of hatred.
- I will refrain from entertaining hatred when it arises.
- I will refrain from attending to things that gives rise to hatred.
Suddenly there is a sense of context for your conduct. You can situate yourself somewhere on the path of transformation, somewhere more definite than “not at the end.” Although you should always keep your ultimate destination in the back of your mind, you also need to be able to focus on the stretch of path that is right in front of you. Precepts illuminate that path.
When you associate with good spiritual friends, you will find that their virtues will grow in you quite spontaneously. You will also be surprised to see that there are seeds in you, things that you completely take for granted, that will nourish the people around you. When you practice alone, the virtue that you cultivate only grows in you. But when you practice in a Sangha, it is multiplied by every other member.
Shared Resources
My teacher would talk about the Sangha Body as a living thing, the health of which is maintained by the practice of each individual person, each cell. The Sangha is the practice community, incorporated, in the most general usage of that word. This collective entity can hold property. Once material resources are consecrated to the Sangha, their use is determined by the decision-making council. Traditionally there are even things that are beyond the purview of this council to dispose of because they are dedicated to the benefit of the Sangha of past, present, and future. I only add this detail because I think it’s neat.
There are also intangible resources like time, capacity, or even a habit. These, I think, require much more consideration in the information age. To my mind the foremost intangible resource of the Sangha is the desire to practice. Share it.
No Proprietor
Although there is much to be made of the compassion and generosity of the Buddha, I prefer to think of his decision to teach as something very basic and simple. From our perspective, breathing out carbon dioxide is less than an afterthought. From the perspective of a tree, however, it is the difference between life and death. This is the best way to share with the Sangha. It does not have to feel like generosity, or even like sharing. You do not need to have something special in order to contribute. But even if it feels like doing nothing, don’t denigrate it either, because you may never know what it means to somebody else. The best is if it feels just like breathing.